Mini journal logo  Home Issue Contents All Issues ☰

Selecting sites and telling stories: fieldwork practice and emerging narratives for the archaeology of HS2 Phase One

John Halsted

Cite this as: Halsted, J. 2024 Selecting sites and telling stories: fieldwork practice and emerging narratives for the archaeology of HS2 Phase One, Internet Archaeology 67. https://doi.org/10.11141/ia.67.18

Summary

App homepage
Romano-British stone sculpture from St Mary's Church, Stoke Mandeville, Buckinghamshire. Image credit: ©HS2 Ltd

The interpretation of our investigations into the past, which can explore the chronological development of a site, the activities of its inhabitants or the environment in which they lived, culminate in the formation of archaeological narratives. These may take the form of a discussion in an archaeological report, a conference presentation or a story in the media. The narratives we develop as a result of archaeological fieldwork are directly influenced by the methodologies we employ. On a large-scale project such as HS2 Phase One, those methodologies can include a variety of survey and sampling strategies, culminating in the selection of specific locations for further investigation. The methodology and decision-making process has been influenced by the Specific Objectives as set out in the Historic Environment Research and Delivery Strategy (HERDS). The narratives produced will be generated for both academic historic environment audiences and the wider public, including local communities and school children. This paper will examine the types of narratives and stories that are produced for different audiences and consider which themes are chosen and the extent to which those are influenced by the research questions we have set out.

  • Google Scholar
  • Keywords: narratives, fieldwork, HS2, methods, strategies, media, community, HERDS
  • Accepted: 4 July 2024. Published: 11 November 2024
  • Funding: The publication of this article is funded by HS2 Limited, as part of the HS2 Historic Environment Digital Archive.
  • PDF download (main article text only)

Corresponding author: John Halsted
John.Halsted1@hs2.org.uk
HS2 Ltd

Full text

Figure 1: Romano-British stone sculpture from St Mary's Church, Stoke Mandeville, Buckinghamshire. Image credit: ©HS2 Ltd.

Figure 2: Exhibition showing representations of people excavated from St James's Gardens, Euston. Displayed at St James's Church, Piccadilly. Image credit: ©HS2 Ltd.

Figure 3: Showing the excavated gatehouse at Coleshill, Warwickshire. Image credit: ©HS2 Ltd.

Bradley, R. 1998 The Passage of Arms: an archaeological analysis of prehistoric hoard and votive deposits, 2nd edition, Oxford: Oxbow Books.

Bradley, R. 2017 A Geography of Offerings: deposits of valuables in the landscapes of ancient Europe. Oxford: Oxbow Books.

Bradley, R. 2023a 'WP 029C - Historic Environment Works - Coleshill Moated Site Phase 2.1 - Final Factual Report for Archaeological Mitigation', LM report for HS2 Ltd 1EW04-LMJ_WEX-EV-REP-NS04_NL10-029011.

Bradley, R. 2023b 'WP29C - Historic Environment Works - Coleshill Moated Site Phase 2.2 and 3 - Final Factual Report for Archaeological Mitigation', LM report for HS2 Ltd, 1EW04-LMJ_WEX-EV-REP-NS04_NL10-029012.

Brown, A., Hopla, E., Farrington McCabe, A. and Generalski Sparling, S. 2017 'Geoarchaeological Desk Based Assessment (GDBA): Review of the geoarchaeological potential of High Speed Two Phase One', Atkins/ EDP for HS2 Ltd, 1D037-EDP-EV-REP-000-000031.

Carver, J. 2020 'Project Plan for assessment and investigation of no-data (blank) areas', Fusion report for HS2 Ltd, 1EW03-FUS-EV-REP-C000-009810.

CIFA 2022 'Evaluation Strategies (Evals 1): understanding current practice and encouraging sector engagement', WSP for the Chartered Institute of Archaeologists, https://www.archaeologists.net/sites/default/files/projects/EVALS%201%20Final%20Report%20for%20publication.pdf [Last accessed: March 2024]

Fitzpatrick, K. 2023 'WP 029C - Historic Environment Works - Coleshill Moated Site - Final Factual Report', LM report for HS2 Ltd, 1EW04-LMJ_WEX-EV-REP-NS04_NL10-029007.

Franklin, J., Bryant Buck, H., Walker, D., Milby, S., Williams, A. and Bayliss, A. 2021 'WP 014 - Historic Environment Works - Park Street Burial Ground - Factual Fieldwork Report and Post-Excavation Assessment', LM report for HS2 Ltd, 1EW04-LMJ_HAU-EV-REP-NS08-014001.

Fulford, M. and Holbrook, N. 2011 'Assessing the contribution of commercial archaeology to the study of the Roman period in England 1990-2004', Antiquaries Journal 91, 323-345. https://doi.org/10.1017⁄s0003581511000138

Gardner, T. 2019 'Assessing the contribution of integrated geoarchaeological approaches to understand the formation and function of burnt mounds: the example of Hoppenwood Bank, North Northumberland', Archaeological Journal 176(1), 51-83. https://doi.org/10.1080/00665983.2018.1463648

Gosden. C, Green, C., Cooper, A., Creswell, M., Donnelly, V., Franconi, T., Glyde, R., Kamash, Z., Mallet, A., Morley, L., Stansbie, D. and ten Harkel. L. 2021 English Landscapes and Identities: Investigating landscape change from 1500BC to AD1086, Oxford University Press: Oxford. https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780198870623.001.0001

Hartle, R. 2022 'St James's Gardens Post-Excavation Assessment', MOLA/ Mace Dragados report for HS2 Ltd, 1CP01-MDS_MLA-EV-REP-SS08_SL44-000003.

Hartle, R. 2024 'The Corporation of Corpse Stealers: archaeological and historical evidence of bodysnatching in early Eighteenth Century London' in E. Craig-Atkins and K. Harvey (eds) The Material Body: embodiment, history and archaeology and industrialising England 1700-1850, Manchester: Manchester University Press. 100-133. https://doi.org/10.7765/9781526152794

Henig, M., Coombe, P. and Hayward, K. 2022 'Sculpture' in T. Swannick, 'Post-Excavation Assessment Report for Archaeological Recording at St. Mary's C22020, C22024, C22025 - Stoke Mandeville, Buckinghamshire', HS2 Ltd, report 1EW03-FUS_LAR-EV-REP-CS03_CL17-000019, 145-151.

Hey, G. 2006 'Scale and Archaeological Evaluations: What are we looking for?' in G. Lock and B. Molyneaux (eds) Confronting Scale in Archaeology: Issues of Theory and Practice, New York: Springer. 113-128. https://doi.org/10.1007/0-387-32772-3_8

Hey, G. and Lacey, M. 2001 Evaluation of archaeological decision-making processes and sampling strategies, Oxford: Oxford Archaeological Unit.

Higham, R. forthcoming Evaluating archaeological evaluation trenching strategies using GIS, PhD thesis, University of Brighton.

Howard, A. 2021 'AWHh Project Plan for a Route-wide Central Palaeoenvironmental Evaluation', Fusion for HS2 Ltd, report 1EW03-FUS-EV-REP-C000-009813.

Howard, A. and Hopla, E. 2017 'Scheme-wide palaeo-environmental Detailed Desk Based Assessment', Atkins/ EDP for HS2 Ltd, 1D037-EDP-EV-REP-000-000033.

Jenkins, M. and Cooke, N. 2017 'Detailed Desk Based Assessment: St Mary the Virgin, Stoke Mandeville', Atkins/ EDP for HS2 Ltd, report 1D008-EDP-EV-ASM-000-000005.

Meier, T. 2013 '‘'Archaeology and Identity in a Bavarian Village' in E. Niklasson and T. Meier (eds) Appropriate Narratives, archaeologists, publics and stories, Budapest: Archaeolingua Foundation. 145-184.

Millward, J. 2017a 'Detailed Desk Based Assessment Coleshill', Atkins/ EDP for HS2 Ltd, report 1D037-EDP-EV-REP-030-000024.

Millward, J. 2017b 'Detailed Desk Based Assessment Doddershall Quainton', Atkins/ EDP for HS2 Ltd, report 1D037-EDP-EV-REP-040-000036.

Ratkai, S. 2022 Pottery' in K. Fitzpatrick 'WP 029C - Historic Environment Works - Coleshill Moated Site - Final Factual Report', LM report for HS2 Ltd, 1EW04-LMJ_WEX-EV-REP-NS04_NL10-029007. 122-131.

Ratkai, S. 2023 'Pottery' in R. Bradley 'WP29C - Historic Environment Works - Coleshill Moated Site Phase 2.2 and 3 - Final Factual Report for Archaeological Mitigation', LM report for HS2 Ltd, 1EW04-LMJ_WEX-EV-REP-NS04_NL10-029012. 96-103.

Shaw, A. and Brown, A. 2022 'WP 029A - Historic Environment Works - Areas 1-3: Geoarchaeological investigations, Stage B: Geoarchaeological Fieldwork', LM/DJV for HS2 Ltd, 1EW04-LMJ_WEX-EV-REP-N000-029001.

Smith, A., Allen, M., Brindle, T. and Fulford, M. 2016 The Rural Settlement of Roman Britain: New Visions of the Countryside of Roman Britain, Volume 1, Britannia Monograph 29, London: Society of the Promotion of Roman Studies.

Spandle, K. 2019 'WP 029(a) - Detailed Desk Based Assessment: Historic Settlement Landscape', LM/DJV for HS2 Ltd, 1EW04-LMJ-EV-REP-N000-029001.

Wells, T. 2017a 'Colne Valley East Detailed Desk Based Assessment', Atkins/EDP for HS2 Ltd, 1D037-EDP-EV-REP-S000-000004.

Wells, T. 2017b 'Colne Valley West Detailed Desk Based Assessment', Atkins/EDP for HS2 Ltd, 1D037-EDP-EV-REP-C000-000028.

Internet Archaeology is an open access journal based in the Department of Archaeology, University of York. Except where otherwise noted, content from this work may be used under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 (CC BY) Unported licence, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided that attribution to the author(s), the title of the work, the Internet Archaeology journal and the relevant URL/DOI are given.

Terms and Conditions | Legal Statements | Privacy Policy | Cookies Policy | Citing Internet Archaeology

Internet Archaeology content is preserved for the long term with the Archaeology Data Service. Help sustain and support open access publication by donating to our Open Access Archaeology Fund.