So far we have described some case studies exemplifying a range of off-line visualisation systems available today. We will now consider recent efforts aimed at developing cyber-infrastructures for the on-line visualisation of 3D archaeological data. A workshop held at the National Sciences Foundation in February 2013 focused on the process of synthesis in archaeology, highlighting the need for investment in computational infrastructures that would assist in overcoming some of the archaeological 'grand challenges' that prevent synthetic research in archaeology. By which we mean problems of preservation, discovery and access, difficulties with data integration, the sheer variety and complexity of archaeological data and evidence, and the disciplinary norms and pragmatics of data sharing and collaboration (Kintigh et al. 2015, 4). This need to reconsider the nature of archaeological research was envisioned a few years ago by Ezra Zubrow, who stressed how I-archaeology would be relevant for an i-world; he argues that I-archaeology 'will change the way people conceive of the past for they will be connected to all of it all of the time if they so wish' (Zubrow 2010, 4).
Starting from the previous assumptions, it is critical to develop cyber-infrastructures that allow us to overcome the impediments to synthesis in archaeology described by Kintigh et al. (2015, 4). These cyber-infrastructures should allow access to a wide variety of data (i.e. 3D reproductions, 3D panoramic videos, RTI images, etc.) that reproduce the site or artefact as realistically and interactively as possible.
Such a 3D web-based visualisation system (3D viewer) should not only address the visualisation component but also be able to integrate a variety of datasets coming from fieldwork campaigns and include hyperlinks (i.e. links to pictures, 3D models, text, etc.). These should provide a range of audiences with varied information on the layers detected, excavation area, and methodologies used during fieldwork, and, in addition, links between the layers and artefacts or other material remains found on site etc. Mark Aldenderfer argues that 3D viewers should allow for simultaneous visualisation of 3D contents and all inferences enhanced by 3D replicas and simulations:
What I have in mind as a set of tools for visualisation in service of archaeological simulation doesn't really exist yet in our field. We must develop tools and approaches that allow us to simultaneously 'see' (i.e. to create images that may represent a wide variety of information content across a variety of media types) and to 'know' (i.e. to be able to connect these disparate images to other kinds of data) such that inference is enhanced and enabled (Aldenderfer 2010, 55).
In other words, this kind of interactive application should give scholars and the general public, as well as other stakeholders interested in these fields of study, the opportunity to access and visualise various datasets, favouring and enabling multiple interpretations of the same archaeological context and facilitating greater synthesis in archaeology as a result of better interconnectivity between researchers and practitioners in the fields of heritage and archaeology.
The visualisation of 3D contents was one of the main goals of the European-funded project CARARE. CARARE gave users the capability to visualise 3D models in real-time, but the information on these models can only be seen separately from the 3D models. In other words it is not possible to visualise 3D models and site information simultaneously.
The development of a complex real-time system for the data management, analysis, and visualisation of archaeological sites, using 3D realistic and metric reproduction of the archaeological units instead of schematic graphic representation, is a controversial and frequently discussed topic among digital archaeologists today. This is because the creation of a 3D web-based platform for the analysis and interpretation of archaeological data requires overcoming substantial technical and methodological challenges, including:
As described above, complex visualisation systems already exist, but they are mainly off-line platforms designed to present monuments and archaeological sites to the general public. The challenge now is to combine this interaction, alongside analysis and interpretation of these virtual environments, with related datasets on the wider web. The creation of standardised and complex databases for the preservation and sharing of the archaeological record is becoming more widespread in archaeology. Two of the most important and successful examples of data services supporting research and education in archaeology are the Archaeology Data Service (ADS) and the Digital Archaeological Record (tDAR). The ADS was established in September 1996 at the University of York, while tDAR was developed at Arizona State University in 2008 as part of the Digital Antiquity initiative. There are also examples of European-funded projects that are trying to bring together and integrate existing archaeological research data infrastructures, such as the ARIADNE project (Niccolucci and Richards 2013).
This on-going commitment of the European Research Council to support cyber-infrastructures that enhance and promote access and preservation of European Cultural Heritage requires further research and improvements in the integration of the 3D component on the web. Although there have been some attempts to create prototype management systems for the visualisation of 3D representations of the archaeological record (Losier et al. 2007; Doneus et al. 2011; Stal et al. 2014; Trautner 2015), none of them is integrated within stable digital archives that allow for the long-term preservation and dissemination of those data.
As part of European efforts to design and develop complex cyber infrastructure, the European-funded project ADS 3D Viewer: a 3D Real-Time System for the Management and Analysis of Archaeological Data developed a 3D web-based resource for the management and analysis of archaeological data within the Archaeology Data Service. The ADS 3D viewer was created to take advantage of recent developments in web technology (Web Graphics Library: WebGL) by current web browsers. This project originates from an on-going collaboration between the ADS and the Visual Computing Lab (ISTI-CNR, Pisa) in the framework of the ARIADNE European project (Niccolucci and Richards 2013). Combining the potential of the 3D Heritage Online Presenter (3DHOP; Potenziani et al. 2015), a software package for the web-based visualisation of 3D geometries, with the infrastructure of the ADS repository, the 3D Viewer project created a platform for the visualisation and analysis of 3D data archived by the ADS (Galeazzi et al. 2016).
The methodology used in developing the 3D viewer was shaped by three main objectives:
The two versions of the viewer developed in this project, the Object Level 3D Viewer (implemented to extend the browsing capability of ADS project archives by enabling the visualisation of single 3D models) and the Stratigraphy 3D Viewer (implemented in order to allow the exploration of a specific kind of aggregated data: the multiple layers of an archaeological stratigraphic sequence), are designed to answer the different needs of users. These platforms allow those unable to participate directly in the fieldwork to access, analyse and re-interpret the archaeological context remotely, and are likely to help favourably transform the discipline, by nurturing inter-disciplinarity, and cross-border and 'at-distance' collaborative workflows. We are confident that the ADS 3D Viewer is a tool that could play a significant role in the integration of both traditional and innovative digital acquisition methods in day-to-day fieldwork practice.
Internet Archaeology is an open access journal based in the Department of Archaeology, University of York. Except where otherwise noted, content from this work may be used under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 (CC BY) Unported licence, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided that attribution to the author(s), the title of the work, the Internet Archaeology journal and the relevant URL/DOI are given.
Internet Archaeology content is preserved for the long term with the Archaeology Data Service. Help sustain and support open access publication by donating to our Open Access Archaeology Fund.